No, There was a flame war after I said to Person 2 "You just repeated what Person 1 said"
Some Agree with me, And Some Flame me.
You should be saying that.
Technically speaking, "person one" is new to the Internet/Fandom/world/ponies and tries to say something he/she/it thinks new to other people.
"person two" is not that new, but for some reason tries to deliver to "person one" simple rule "nobody gives a fuck, so shouldn't give you". Still, that "person two" isn't experienced enough to follow this rule himself/herself/itself.
Does it answers your question?
They're not the same argument, they're just working from the same premise to draw different conclusions.
Premise: Everyone's opinions about the quality of things are equally valid.
Conclusion 1: So we shouldn't flame people for liking/hating things because their opinions are valid.
Conclusion 2: So we should feel free to flame people for liking/hating things because our opinions are valid.
Edit: SMBC was relevant today:
Pro psaní komentáře se přihlaste.
Person 1
: I still don't understand why people insist on forcing their opinions on others. What ever happened to simply enjoying something because you like it? Who cares if someone thinks this is the worst thing ever. As long as you enjoy the series why should anyone else's opinion matter to you? Just saying, it's time for some of you to grow up.
Person 2 Contradicting Person 1
: I don't see anyone forcing opinions on people here except you perhaps ,? People are allowed to express their opinion whether you like it or not so I think you should take your own advice and grow up people will say thing you don't like love with it and people will take note of others opinion even if you don't like it
I see many smart people here in this forums Dota related or not.
So I'm asking if did Person 2 repeat what Person 1 said?
Edit : If you want to see the Argument, This is the Link.
https://plus.google.com/101743287111935070134/posts/UmeDkqinXqa
Lol we're arguing about an Anime.